Skip to content
  1. Home
  2. For parents
  3. Rewards, Stickers and Motivation: What Works for Kids
⭐ Parent guide · 6 min read

Rewards, Stickers and Motivation: What Works for Kids

Do sticker charts and rewards help or hurt? How intrinsic and extrinsic motivation work in kids, when rewards make sense, and better ways to build inner drive.

Sticker charts hang on a lot of refrigerators. Stars for brushing teeth, stars for reading, stars for not hitting your brother. Some families swear by them. Others find that after a week, the chart is forgotten, or worse, the kids start negotiating: “How many stickers do I get if I clear the table?”

So do rewards work? Sometimes, for some things, if you use them carefully. Understanding a little about motivation helps you decide when.

Two kinds of motivation

Psychologists often describe motivation in two broad types.

Intrinsic motivation is doing something because it’s interesting, enjoyable or worthwhile in itself. A child who builds an elaborate block castle for an hour, just because, is intrinsically motivated. Nobody had to pay them.

Extrinsic motivation is doing something to get something else: a sticker, screen time, praise, money, or avoiding getting in trouble. Most of us do plenty of things for extrinsic reasons (going to the dentist, filing taxes), and that’s fine.

Most everyday motivation is a mix. A child might start piano lessons because a parent insists, keep going because of a gold star from the teacher, and eventually play because they love it.

What research says about rewards

Decades of psychology research, including the work of Edward Deci and Richard Ryan on what they call self-determination theory, has looked at how rewards affect motivation. A few findings come up again and again.

Rewards can undermine interest in things kids already enjoy. In classic experiments, children who were promised a reward for an activity they already liked, such as drawing, sometimes showed less interest in it later, once rewards stopped. The activity had shifted from “something I like” to “something I do for a prize.”

Rewards work better for tasks that aren’t interesting. If a task is boring, like practicing a routine, a reward doesn’t have much interest to undermine. It can help get a habit started.

People are more motivated when they feel three things: a sense of choice and control (autonomy), a sense of being good at something (competence), and connection with others (relatedness). These ideas are central to self-determination theory, and they’re useful for parents.

When rewards make sense

Rewards can be a reasonable tool when:

  • The task isn’t naturally enjoyable: toilet training, brushing teeth, tidying up, practicing a tough skill.
  • The goal is specific and short-term: “Stay in your own bed all night” rather than “Be good.”
  • You’re building a new routine that will eventually become automatic.
  • The reward is small and immediate: a sticker right away, not a big toy in three weeks.

How to use a sticker chart well

  1. Pick one or two specific behaviors. “Put shoes on by 8:00” is clearer than “Get ready nicely.”
  2. Make it achievable. Early success keeps kids engaged.
  3. Give the sticker right away, with specific praise: “You got your shoes on all by yourself!”
  4. Keep it temporary. Plan to fade it after a few weeks once the habit is established.
  5. Celebrate together when the chart is full, perhaps with a special activity rather than a purchase.
  6. Don’t take stickers away as punishment. That tends to turn the chart into a source of conflict.

When rewards can backfire

  • Rewarding things kids already enjoy, like reading or drawing. Paying for books read can shift the focus to quantity, with children racing through short, easy books.
  • Escalating rewards. “Last time I got a sticker. Now I want a toy.”
  • Constant bribery. “If you stop crying, you can have a cookie” can teach that crying earns cookies.
  • Rewards for everything. If every small task earns a prize, nothing feels worth doing without one.

Building intrinsic motivation

The deeper goal is a child who wants to learn and try things for their own sake. Here’s how to nurture that.

Offer choices that count

Choice builds a sense of control. “Do you want to practice spelling words with magnets or chalk?” “Which book shall we read?” “Do you want to do math first or reading first?” Even small choices make children more willing.

Keep the challenge just right

Children love feeling competent. Tasks that are too hard feel hopeless; tasks that are too easy feel boring. Aim for the zone where they have to stretch a bit but can succeed. That’s where the satisfying “I did it!” moments happen.

Praise effort and strategy, specifically

Carol Dweck’s research on mindset suggests that praising intelligence (“You’re so smart”) can make children cautious about trying hard things, in case they fail and look less smart. Praising effort and strategies tends to encourage persistence.

Compare:

  • “You’re a natural artist.” versus “You added so many details to the dragon’s wings. I can tell you took your time.”
  • “Good job.” versus “You kept going even when that puzzle was frustrating, and you figured it out.”

Show your own enthusiasm

Children notice what you care about. If you read for pleasure, play music, get curious about how things work or enjoy solving puzzles, that sends a powerful message.

Connect learning to their interests

A child obsessed with dinosaurs will happily practice reading if the book is about a T. rex. A sports fan might get interested in averages and percentages. Follow the spark.

Let them see progress

Kids are motivated by noticing that they’re improving. Keep a folder of drawings from September and compare with June. Record them reading aloud now and in three months. In SmartySHIB, the parent report can show which skills your child has been practicing, which makes progress visible and is a good conversation starter.

What about game rewards?

Many children’s games, including ours, use stars, coins and stickers. Used well, these work like a scoreboard: they show progress and give a small sense of accomplishment. On SmartySHIB, children earn stars, collect stickers, and spend coins building their own corner of Pip’s Town.

The key is whether the game itself is worth playing. If a child keeps returning to Tangram Junior or Sudoku Kids because the puzzle is satisfying, the stars are a pleasant bonus. If a child only plays to grab rewards and rushes through without thinking, it’s worth having a chat or trying a different game.

Open-ended, creative games like Pixel Artist, Little Builder, Story Maker and Piano Keys are good for intrinsic motivation, because the reward is the thing you made.

A quick guide by age

Ages 3 to 5. Short-term sticker charts can help with routines. Lots of specific praise and enthusiasm. Plenty of free play, which is intrinsically motivating by nature.

Ages 6 to 8. Choice and competence matter more. Kids love mastering skills and showing you. Charts can still help with tricky routines, but fade them sooner.

Ages 9 to 10. Involve them in setting goals. “What would you like to get better at this month?” Track progress together.

Ages 11 to 13. Autonomy is huge. Offer choices, respect their interests, and let them own their goals. Pocket money tied to specific extra jobs can work, but avoid paying for schoolwork or basic family contributions.

The long view

Rewards are a tool, not a strategy. They can help get a habit off the ground or get through a hard patch. But the motivation that lasts comes from within: from feeling capable, having some control and sharing the experience with people who care. When your child picks up a book on a Sunday afternoon without being asked, you’ll know it’s working.

Frequently asked questions

Do sticker charts work?
They can help for short-term goals, especially for building a new routine like brushing teeth or using the toilet. They work best when the goal is specific, the chart is temporary and you gradually fade it out.
What is the difference between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation?
Intrinsic motivation means doing something because it is interesting or satisfying in itself. Extrinsic motivation means doing it to get something else, like a reward or to avoid a consequence.
Can rewards reduce a child's motivation?
Psychology research has found that offering expected rewards for activities a child already enjoys can sometimes reduce their interest once the rewards stop. That's why rewards are best saved for tasks that aren't naturally interesting.
What kind of praise works best?
Specific praise about effort, strategy and progress tends to be more helpful than general labels like "smart." For example: "You tried three ways until one worked" rather than "You're so clever."

Games mentioned in this guide