How to Choose a Good Educational Game: A Parent's Checklist
Not every game labeled educational teaches much. Use this parent checklist to spot games that build lasting skills, fit your child's age and respect their time.
The app store and the web are full of games with words like “educational,” “brain-boosting” or “learning” on the label. Some are excellent. Some are flashcards wearing a costume. Many are somewhere in between, and it can be hard to tell which is which from a screenshot.
After years of watching children play (and watching what sticks with them afterward), I have found that a handful of questions sort the good from the forgettable pretty quickly. Here is the checklist I give parents, with the reasoning behind each point.
The quick checklist
Print this, screenshot it, or just keep it in your head:
- Does my child have to think, not just tap?
- Is the learning inside the game, or bolted on?
- Does the game give useful feedback when my child gets something wrong?
- Does it adjust to my child’s level?
- Is it the right length, with a natural place to stop?
- Is it free of manipulation: no pressure to buy, no endless streak guilt?
- Is it safe: no stranger chat, no data collection from kids?
- Can I see what my child is learning?
- Does my child want to play it again?
Let’s go through them.
1. Thinking, not just tapping
The core question is whether the game asks your child to make decisions. In a strong game, the child has to plan a route, figure out a pattern, choose a word, or predict what will happen. In a weak one, the child taps whatever lights up and gets a cheerful sound.
A simple test: could your child succeed by tapping randomly and quickly? If yes, the learning value is probably low.
Arrow Robot is a good example of the opposite. To get the robot to the goal, a child has to plan a sequence of moves in their head before pressing go. If they are wrong, the robot bumps into a wall and they can see exactly where the plan broke.
2. Learning built in, not bolted on
Some games use a “chocolate-covered broccoli” design: answer three math questions, then you get to play the fun part. Kids figure this out fast. They rush the questions to get to the reward, and the learning becomes the thing to get through.
Better games make the skill be the fun. In Fraction Pizzeria, cutting and serving the right fraction of pizza is the game. In Word Builder, building the word is the puzzle. There is no separate quiz to sit through.
3. Feedback that teaches
When a child makes a mistake, what happens? A buzzer and “Try again!” tells them they were wrong but not why. Good feedback shows something: the number line that reveals how far off the jump was, the letter that gets highlighted, the piece that does not fit.
Also watch for feedback that is too harsh. Losing lives, loud failure sounds and big red X marks can make anxious kids give up. For younger children especially, gentle correction works better.
4. It adapts to your child
A game that is too easy is boring within minutes. One that is too hard leads to frustration and random guessing. The sweet spot, where a child succeeds most of the time but has to stretch now and then, is where learning happens.
Look for games that have levels, get harder as your child improves, or let you choose a difficulty. On SmartySHIB, the age and grade pages help you find the right starting point, and many games step up as your child gets answers right.
5. The right length
For children under about 7, a single round or session should be short, a few minutes, so they can finish and feel good about it. Older kids can manage longer play, but a clear end point still matters.
Games designed around endless play, where there is always one more level, one more reward, one more chest to open, make it very hard for children to stop. You end up being the bad guy every time. Games with a defined finish, like a puzzle that is either solved or not, or a short daily challenge, are much kinder to family routines.
6. No manipulation
This one matters a lot to me. Be wary of games that:
- Ask children to buy coins, gems or extra lives
- Use countdown timers to pressure purchases (“Offer ends in 3 minutes!”)
- Punish missed days by taking away progress or streaks
- Show characters who are sad or disappointed when the child stops playing
These are design tricks aimed at keeping kids hooked, not helping them learn. A good children’s game should be something your child can walk away from at any time without feeling guilty.
7. Safety and privacy
For young children, there should be no open chat with strangers, no social features that expose their name or photo, and no request for an email or location. If a game is ad-supported, ads should be clearly separate from play so a child doesn’t tap them by accident while aiming at a game button. SmartySHIB games, for example, need no sign-up, and progress is saved on your own device rather than in an account.
If you are not sure, play the game yourself for ten minutes first. You will learn more in those ten minutes than from any review.
8. You can see the learning
It helps to know which skills a game works on. Does it build phonics, number sense, working memory, spatial reasoning? Good educational sites tell you this plainly.
It is even better when you can see your child’s progress. The SmartySHIB parent report shows which skills your child has practiced and how much, which makes it easier to notice when they keep replaying a game that is now far too easy.
9. Your child wants to come back
Finally, the honest test. A game can tick every box above and still sit unplayed because it is dull. Children should want to return to a good educational game. If your child asks for it by name, or tells you about a level at dinner, you have found a keeper.
Matching games to age
A few rough pointers:
Ages 3 to 4. Big buttons, no reading required, spoken instructions, no timers. Matching, sorting, counting, colors and shapes. Try Shape Train or Big and Small.
Ages 5 to 6. Early phonics, counting to 20 and beyond, simple patterns. Short rounds. First Sounds, Number Path and Pattern Bridge fit here.
Ages 7 to 8. Fluency practice (math facts, sight words, spelling), early coding and logic. Children can now read simple instructions themselves.
Ages 9 to 10. Strategy, multi-step problems, typing, fractions, geography. Puzzles like Sudoku Kids become satisfying.
Ages 11 to 13. Simulations, science, money, critical thinking. Kids this age respond well to games that treat them as capable, like City Mayor or Truth Newsroom.
A ten-minute test drive
Before handing a new game to your child, try this:
- Play it yourself for five minutes. Note what skill it seems to target.
- Make a deliberate mistake. Does the feedback help?
- Look for purchase buttons, chat boxes, or requests for personal info.
- Check how a round ends. Is there a natural stopping point?
- Then play it with your child for five minutes and watch their face.
That last step tells you the most. A child who leans in, frowns in concentration and then grins when something clicks is learning. A child who taps on autopilot while staring past the screen is not, however colorful the game is.
One last thought
No game, however well designed, replaces conversation, books, outdoor play and hands-on making. The best educational games are a good supplement: a focused way to practice a skill, or a spark that leads to something off-screen. If a game sends your child running to build a block tower, write a story or count the coins in their piggy bank, it has done its job.